Faith Congregational Church (Talcott Street Congregational)
Faith Congregational Church and Its Mission:
Faith Congregational Church, formerly known as the Talcott Street Congregational Church, is the oldest African American church in Hartford and the first Black Congregational Church in Connecticut, founded in 1819. From its earliest days, the church has stood as a beacon of faith, education, resistance, and community leadership for African Americans in Hartford.
Formed in protest against segregated seating in white churches, the founders established a congregation where everyone was welcome and equal. Over two centuries, the church has remained committed to that vision—serving as a religious, educational, and civil rights institution with an unwavering focus on justice and dignity.
Hartford’s Role in Abolition and Black Self-Determination
In 1826, the congregation purchased land at the corner of Talcott and Market Streets, where they built a stone-and-brick church that would become a hub for abolitionist organizing and intellectual life in Hartford’s Black community. Lecturers such as Rev. Henry Highland Garnet and Arnold Buffum helped establish the church as a critical meetinghouse for the anti-slavery movement.
Understanding the necessity of education, church leaders also founded a district school—the only place in Hartford for years where Black children could learn to read and write.
James W.C. Pennington and the Fight for Freedom
Among the most notable pastors in the church’s early history was Rev. Dr. James W.C. Pennington, an escaped slave who became a renowned orator, theologian, and activist. Constantly at risk of being recaptured, Pennington received his official freedom in 1851 when John Hooker, the brother-in-law of Harriet Beecher Stowe, purchased his freedom for $150.
Pennington’s Bible, still housed at the church today, stands as a living relic of his legacy and the larger struggle for freedom and humanity.
A Century of Growth and Transformation
By the late 19th century, under the leadership of Rev. Robert F. Wheeler, the congregation had grown significantly, prompting the demolition of the original church in 1906 to make way for a new two-story building. In 1916, the arrival of Rev. Dr. James A. Wright marked a new era. An esteemed theologian and Harvard graduate, Rev. Wright led the church for 43 years, guiding it through world wars and the beginnings of the civil rights movement.
In 1953, the congregation merged with Mother Bethel Methodist Church, forming what is now known as Faith Congregational Church. The unified congregation moved to its current home—2030 Main Street—in 1954, occupying the former Windsor Avenue Congregational Church, originally built in 1871.
Faith Through Fire and Renewal
In 1959, a devastating three-alarm fire severely damaged the new church during a choir rehearsal. Thanks to swift community action and generous support, the sanctuary was fully restored and reopened on Easter Sunday 1960, just weeks after the passing of Rev. Wright. His books and papers remain part of the church’s treasured archives.
Faith Congregational Church has remained steadfast in its mission to educate, uplift, and empower generations of African Americans in Hartford.
This site is open to the public.